Home › Guide › Stage 6: In contract: escrow to closing

Homeowners Insurance in SF's Hard Market (and the FAIR Plan)

Updated 2026-10-25, 7 minute read

Request three homeowners insurance quotes the day you open escrow. Your lender cannot fund without a bound policy, binding in California can take weeks, and in the California Association of Realtors' 2024 survey 13% of agents had a deal fall out of escrow because the buyer could not get insured. In San Francisco the risk is rarely wildfire; it is the building. Here is what gets SF homes declined, how to shop fast, and how the FAIR Plan works if you need it.

Why California insurance got hard, and why SF is affected anyway

After years of wildfire losses, several large carriers paused or restricted new California policies, and the state's insurer of last resort, the FAIR Plan, swelled. The Department of Insurance's Sustainable Insurance Strategy is bringing capacity back in exchange for letting carriers price catastrophe risk and reinsurance, and rate increases followed: State Farm received a 17% emergency interim increase in 2025, and the Department of Insurance approved a FAIR Plan dwelling-policy increase averaging 29.1% effective October 15, 2026, with the largest increases in wildfire-exposed areas; check current figures.

San Francisco has almost no brush exposure, but carriers restrict by state, not by neighborhood, and their appetite for old buildings shrank at the same time. A 1908 house with original wiring that would have bound in a day in 2019 now gets questions, conditions or a decline. As of 2026-10-24, treat a house premium as a quote you must get, not a number you can look up.

What the lender requires, and when

Most lenders follow Fannie Mae's standard even on jumbo loans: a policy covering the structure at or near its full replacement cost, with a deductible no higher than 5% of the coverage amount, naming the lender as mortgagee. Evidence of insurance and payment of the first year's premium is a prior-to-funding condition, and the premium shows up on your Closing Disclosure as a prepaid. Practically, you need a bound policy, not a quote, about a week before signing so the lender can clear the condition and draw documents.

Start quoting on day one, through three channels

Channel	What it is	Best for
Direct carrier	You buy online or by phone from the insurer	Newer condos, houses with no flags, speed
Captive agent	A local agent selling one company's products	Bundling with auto, a human who knows the carrier's rules
Independent broker	One agent quoting many admitted carriers plus regional and surplus-lines markets	Older houses, prior claims, anything a direct carrier declined, FAIR Plan wraps

Send each one the same inputs: address, year built, square footage, roof age and material, electrical and plumbing updates, foundation type, the inspection and pest reports, and the deductible and coverage you want. Quotes built on different rebuild costs are not comparable. Ask every channel the same question: is there anything about this home you would decline, and would a commitment to replace the wiring or roof within a set period change that?

HO-3 for houses, HO-6 for condos

A house takes an HO-3 policy covering the structure, other structures, contents, loss of use and liability. A condo takes an HO-6, and what it must cover depends on the HOA master policy:

Bare walls master policy: covers the building to the drywall or studs. Your HO-6 covers interior walls, floors, cabinets, fixtures and everything else.
Single entity: covers the unit as originally built, not later upgrades.
All-in: covers the interior too; your HO-6 mainly covers contents, liability, loss of use and loss assessment.

Get the master policy declarations from the HOA package before you quote. Two numbers matter beyond the type: the master deductible, which some associations charge back to the owner whose unit caused a loss, and the renewal date. Associations across California have faced non-renewals and steep premium increases, and a master policy that renews next quarter at a higher cost lands in your dues. Loss assessment coverage on your HO-6 pays your share of a claim that exceeds the master policy; the default limits are small, and raising them is cheap. A San Francisco HO-6 typically runs several hundred dollars a year by published estimates; check current figures. HOA documents covers the rest of the package.

What triggers declines in SF

Knob-and-tube wiring. Bay Area brokers report that disclosing active knob-and-tube now draws declines from standard carriers; some will bind on a commitment to replace within a set window.
Roof age. A roof past roughly 20 years, or a flat roof with no documented replacement, draws inspection requirements or exclusions.
Foundation. Brick or unbolted foundations and unretrofitted soft-story buildings concern carriers less than they concern earthquake insurers, but they appear on applications and some carriers price them.
Claims history. A prior water or fire claim on the property, visible to carriers through shared databases, can surface even if the seller never mentioned it.
Galvanized plumbing, old panels, unpermitted units. Each is a question on the application; each can be a condition.
Brush. Rare in SF, but parcels adjoining large parks or the Presidio edge can be mapped into a higher fire score.

If a condition is the obstacle, the fix is often a dated commitment: a rewire or roof within 60 to 90 days of closing, with the carrier binding now. Price that work into your offer and read SF red flags before you are in contract.

The FAIR Plan plus a difference-in-conditions wrap

If two admitted carriers and a broker have declined, the FAIR Plan will write the home. It is an association of California's licensed insurers, not a state agency, and its dwelling policy covers fire, lightning, smoke and a short list of named perils up to a residential limit that as of 2026-10-24 is in the low millions; check the current limit on the FAIR Plan's site, because a large SF house can exceed it. It does not cover liability, theft or most water damage, so lenders and sensible owners pair it with a difference-in-conditions (DIC) policy from a separate carrier that fills those gaps. The combined premium is higher than a single standard policy, the FAIR Plan's rate is not negotiable, and the DIC market is where the small variance lives. Treat the FAIR Plan as a bridge: fix what got you declined, then ask your broker to remarket to admitted carriers at renewal.

Coverage levels: rebuild cost, not purchase price

Insure the cost to rebuild the structure, not what you paid. In SF most of the price is land, which does not burn, and the rebuild number for a 2,000 square foot house in a dense city with current codes is high. Ask each carrier how it computed replacement cost and whether the policy includes extended replacement cost (a cushion above the limit) and ordinance or law coverage, which pays to rebuild to current code, including seismic and energy requirements an old house does not meet. Older-home exclusions and actual-cash-value roof settlements are common in the fine print; ask directly.

Discounts, deductibles, bundling, and a seven-day plan

Raising the deductible from $1,000 to $2,500 or $5,000 usually cuts the premium meaningfully; stay within the lender's 5% ceiling. Bundling auto, water leak sensors, a monitored alarm, a new roof and a documented electrical update all discount. Then:

Day 1: send identical inputs to a direct carrier, a captive agent and an independent broker.
Day 2: answer every follow-up question the same day; send the inspection reports.
Day 3: compare quotes on the same rebuild cost and deductible; ask the cheapest what would change the price.
Day 4: if declined anywhere, tell the broker immediately and start the FAIR Plan application in parallel.
Day 5: choose, request a binder effective on your closing date, and send the lender's mortgagee clause.
Day 6: confirm the lender received evidence of insurance and that the premium is on the Closing Disclosure.
Day 7: diary the policy's renewal and any repair commitments you made.

What to shop for right now

This is the highest-savings item in escrow. Quotes for the same SF home differ by thousands a year, and the gap between an admitted carrier and the FAIR Plan is bigger still. Three quotes through two channels is the minimum; the broker's access, not a discount on an identical policy, is what you are buying. If you later work with one of this site's agents, the buyer-side commission is how the site is paid, and insurance referrals never are.

Shop for this now

Service	When	Savings from shopping	How to shop it
Homeowners insurance	The day you open escrow, ideally with an indicative quote before you write the offer	High: shop it hard Quotes for the same San Francisco home routinely differ by thousands of dollars a year, and some carriers decline outright while others bind; the saving from three quotes is often the difference between an admitted-carrier policy and the FAIR Plan.	Request three quotes the same day through at least two channels (a direct carrier or captive agent, and an independent broker), using the same rebuild cost, deductible and coverage limits so they compare cleanly. Ask each what would disqualify the home and whether a retrofit or rewire commitment changes the answer.
Independent insurance broker	Same day as your direct quotes, and immediately if a direct carrier declines	Medium: worth 2-3 quotes The broker's value is access rather than a lower premium on the same policy; for an older house or a FAIR Plan wrap, the difference between the markets a broker can reach and the ones you can is often the whole outcome.	Pick a broker who writes a lot of pre-1950 San Francisco property, give them the inspection and pest reports up front, and ask which carriers they will approach and whether any are surplus lines.
FAIR Plan plus DIC wrap	Only after two admitted carriers and a broker have declined	Low: compare once The variance is in the wrap policy and is modest; the real saving is avoiding the FAIR Plan entirely, which is why the broker and the early start matter more than haggling over the wrap.	The FAIR Plan rate is the FAIR Plan rate; shop the difference-in-conditions policy that wraps it across two or three DIC carriers through your broker, and ask about a plan to return to an admitted carrier after a rewire, roof or retrofit.

Frequently asked questions

Is it hard to get homeowners insurance in San Francisco?

Harder than it was, though less so than in wildfire areas. San Francisco has little brush exposure, but the statewide pullback by major carriers applies here, and what gets SF homes declined is the building itself: knob-and-tube wiring, an old roof, a brick or unbolted foundation, prior claims, or a condo master policy that already moved to the FAIR Plan. In the California Association of Realtors' 2024 member survey, 13% of agents had a transaction fall out of escrow because the buyer could not get insurance. Start quoting on day one and most SF buyers get placed.

What is the California FAIR Plan?

The state's insurer of last resort, an association of licensed insurers that writes basic fire coverage for property no admitted carrier will insure. A FAIR Plan dwelling policy covers fire, lightning, smoke and a short list of named perils; it does not include liability, theft or most water damage, so most owners pair it with a difference-in-conditions policy that fills those gaps. It costs more than a standard policy, and the FAIR Plan has been raising rates sharply; the Department of Insurance approved an average increase of 29.1% on dwelling policies effective October 15, 2026, so check current figures.

How much is homeowners insurance in San Francisco?

There is no reliable citywide figure as of 2026-10-24. National comparison sites put California's statewide average at roughly $1,400 to $1,700 a year for $300,000 of dwelling coverage (check current figures), but an older San Francisco house needs far more than $300,000 of rebuild coverage, so a realistic premium is a multiple of that, and quotes for the same house can differ by thousands. A standard HO-6 condo policy in San Francisco typically runs several hundred dollars a year by published estimates, with one comparison site putting the average near $600. Get three quotes; the number is specific to the building.

Does my condo HOA insurance cover the inside of my unit?

Usually only partly. A bare-walls master policy stops at the drywall or studs, a single-entity policy covers the unit as originally built, and an all-in policy covers the interior too. Your HO-6 policy has to fill whatever the master policy leaves out, plus your belongings, liability, loss of use and loss assessment coverage for your share of a claim that exceeds the master policy. Read the master policy declarations before you buy your HO-6, and ask about the master deductible, which can be charged back to you after a water leak.

Can my mortgage be denied because I cannot get insurance?

The loan cannot fund without it. Lenders require a bound policy at or near full replacement cost with a deductible they accept, and evidence of insurance is a standard prior-to-funding condition. If no admitted carrier will write the home, a FAIR Plan policy with a difference-in-conditions wrap generally satisfies the lender, so a denial from carriers delays closing rather than ending it, as long as you started early enough to get the FAIR Plan bound in time.

Should I use an insurance broker or buy directly?

Do both. Direct carriers and captive agents (one company's products) are fast and sometimes cheapest for a newer condo or a house with no red flags. An independent broker can quote several admitted carriers at once and reach regional and surplus-lines markets that direct shoppers never see, which matters most for an older SF house, a prior claim, or anything a direct carrier has already declined. Three quotes through at least two channels is the minimum.