Home › Outer Mission › Cayuga Av
2257 Cayuga Av
Single-family home, 3 bd, 3 ba, 1,185 sqft, built 1924
Today’s estimate uses 1,185 sqft and the home’s latest facts. It does not estimate the home’s value at a past sale date.
81 sales inside 0.75 mi since May 2025. Click a sale on the map, or untick it below, to leave it out.
Drag the circle or this strip to change the searchEstimated sale price today
Medium confidence
$1,174,000
$845,000estimated range$1,444,000
From 81 comps at a weighted median of $991 per sqft.
- Block
- 7145
- Lot
- 058
- Sales
- Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
- Prices adjusted to
- 2026-11-01
- Within
- 0.75 mi
- Sold since
- May 2025
What other buyers offered
No one has reported a losing offer on this home yet.
Create a free account to see offers and add yours
Free, and there is no password: we email you a sign-in code. Already a member? The same button signs you in.
Interested in this home?
Answer a few quick questions and we'll show you what to do next, from getting pre-approved to making an offer.
I'm interestedSale prices versus asking
Similarity-weighted median: 20.0% above final asking.
Middle half: 5.5% above asking to 24.9% above asking.
65 of 81 selected comps have a verified final asking price.
Comparisons use the final advertised asking price from the same sale, before pending or closing.
Comparable sales (81)
Every sale inside the circle starts ticked. Untick one here, or click it on the map, to leave it out. Closer, more similar sales weigh more.
| Address | Sold | Price | Final asking | Sale vs. asking | Adj. today | $/sqft | Size | Dist. | Why | Match | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 151 Josiah Ave | 2026-08-28 | $1.23M | $999,888 | $225,112 above asking (22.5%) | $1.29M | $1,086 | 3bd 2ba 1,192sf | 0.54 mi | similar size, 3 bd, recent | ||
| 25 Farallones St | 2026-09-29 | $721K | $795,000 | $74,000 below asking (9.3%) | $721K | $707 | 3bd 2ba 1,020sf | 0.33 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 738 Plymouth Avenue | 2026-09-02 | $1.2M | $995,000 | $205,000 above asking (20.6%) | $1.2M | $1,000 | 3bd 2ba 1,200sf | 0.54 mi | similar size, 3 bd, recent | ||
| 140 Naglee Ave | 2026-09-14 | $1.2M | $1,198,000 | $2,000 above asking (0.2%) | $1.2M | $991 | 2bd 1ba 1,211sf | 0.49 mi | similar size, recent | ||
| 263 Wilson St | 2026-03-06 | $1M | $799,000 | $201,000 above asking (25.2%) | $1.04M | $921 | 3bd 1ba 1,127sf | 0.36 mi | similar size, 3 bd | ||
| 319 Plymouth Ave | 2026-05-12 | $1.05M | $1,095,000 | $45,000 below asking (4.1%) | $1.09M | $776 | 3bd 1ba 1,400sf | 0.29 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 57 Florentine St | 2026-07-16 | $1.05M | No asking price | — | $1.12M | $956 | 1ba 1,174sf | 0.68 mi | similar size | ||
| 2273 Cayuga Ave | 2026-06-23 | $1.08M | $1,025,000 | $55,000 above asking (5.4%) | $1.12M | $655 | 2bd 2ba 1,709sf | <0.05 mi | nearby on same street | ||
| 88 Lobos St | 2026-04-07 | $1.12M | $968,000 | $152,000 above asking (15.7%) | $1.15M | $900 | 3bd 1ba 1,275sf | 0.40 mi | similar size, 3 bd | ||
| 1670 Cayuga Ave | 2026-07-10 | $1.2M | $998,000 | $202,000 above asking (20.2%) | $1.28M | $1,031 | 2bd 1ba 1,238sf | 0.59 mi | same street, similar size | ||
| 126 Randolph St | 2026-08-04 | $1.18M | $989,000 | $191,000 above asking (19.3%) | $1.25M | $1,073 | 2bd 2ba 1,162sf | 0.60 mi | similar size, recent | ||
| 190 Sagamore St | 2026-07-07 | $1.03M | $950,000 | $80,000 above asking (8.4%) | $1.1M | $1,130 | 2bd 1ba 970sf | 0.25 mi | |||
| 15 Faxon Ave | 2026-07-07 | $1.22M | $998,000 | $222,000 above asking (22.2%) | $1.3M | $1,036 | 3bd 3ba 1,253sf | 0.59 mi | similar size, 3 bd | ||
| 89 Farallones St | 2026-09-29 | $850K | $799,000 | $51,000 above asking (6.4%) | $850K | $873 | 5bd 3ba 974sf | 0.31 mi | recent | ||
| 168 Laura St | 2026-02-23 | $1M | $1,100,000 | $100,000 below asking (9.1%) | $1.07M | $756 | 2bd 2ba 1,415sf | 0.23 mi | |||
| 134 Sears St | 2026-04-21 | $980K | $925,000 | $55,000 above asking (5.9%) | $1M | $628 | 2bd 2ba 1,600sf | <0.05 mi | |||
| 318 Louisburg St | 2026-09-10 | $1.5M | $1,195,000 | $305,000 above asking (25.5%) | $1.5M | $1,200 | 2bd 1ba 1,250sf | 0.71 mi | similar size, recent | ||
| 266 Farallones St | 2026-10-14 | $555K | $449,000 | $106,000 above asking (23.6%) | $532K | $406 | 0bd 1ba 1,310sf | 0.48 mi | recent | ||
| 236 Farallones St | 2026-04-10 | $850K | No asking price | — | $871K | $655 | 1ba 1,330sf | 0.45 mi | |||
| 725 Lakeview Ave | 2026-04-30 | $1.4M | $1,195,000 | $205,000 above asking (17.2%) | $1.43M | $1,148 | 3bd 3ba 1,250sf | 0.65 mi | similar size, 3 bd | ||
| 451 Huron Ave | 2026-02-06 | $1.18M | $899,000 | $276,000 above asking (30.7%) | $1.26M | $1,034 | 2bd 1ba 1,215sf | 0.61 mi | similar size | ||
| 231 Grafton Ave | 2026-08-06 | $1.08M | $999,950 | $80,050 above asking (8.0%) | $1.14M | $1,113 | 3bd 1ba 1,025sf | 0.73 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 246 Ottawa Ave | 2026-06-18 | $1.41M | $998,000 | $410,001 above asking (41.1%) | $1.46M | $1,167 | 2bd 1ba 1,250sf | 0.67 mi | similar size | ||
| 42 Granada Ave | 2026-07-08 | $1.7M | $1,368,000 | $332,000 above asking (24.3%) | $1.81M | $1,622 | 4bd 3ba 1,115sf | 0.67 mi | similar size | ||
| 53 Foote Ave | 2026-01-15 | $1.13M | $899,000 | $232,000 above asking (25.8%) | $1.32M | $1,014 | 3bd 1ba 1,300sf | 0.59 mi | similar size, 3 bd | ||
| 2921 Alemany Boulevard | 2025-11-26 | $1.03M | $998,000 | $37,000 above asking (3.7%) | $1.21M | $856 | 2bd 1ba 1,409sf | 0.24 mi | |||
| 112 Ellington Ave | 2026-02-11 | $1.16M | $929,000 | $231,000 above asking (24.9%) | $1.24M | $1,021 | 2bd 1ba 1,215sf | 0.74 mi | similar size | ||
| 2463 Alemany Blvd | 2026-01-28 | $1.05M | No asking price | — | $1.22M | $1,008 | 1ba 1,214sf | 0.68 mi | similar size | ||
| 61 Farragut Ave | 2026-08-13 | $1.43M | $928,000 | $502,000 above asking (54.1%) | $1.51M | $833 | 3bd 2ba 1,813sf | 0.27 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 258 Victoria St | 2026-07-06 | $1.4M | $999,000 | $401,000 above asking (40.1%) | $1.49M | $1,060 | 3bd 2ba 1,405sf | 0.68 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 326 Rome St | 2026-09-30 | $1.2M | $995,000 | $205,000 above asking (20.6%) | $1.2M | $819 | 4bd 2ba 1,465sf | 0.62 mi | recent | ||
| 482 Orizaba Ave | 2026-08-24 | $1.22M | $999,000 | $221,000 above asking (22.1%) | $1.29M | $1,227 | 2bd 1ba 1,050sf | 0.70 mi | recent | ||
| 515 Head St | 2025-12-26 | $1.1M | $795,000 | $305,000 above asking (38.4%) | $1.3M | $1,067 | 3bd 2ba 1,220sf | 0.71 mi | similar size, 3 bd | ||
| 542 Head St | 2026-02-24 | $1.27M | $998,000 | $270,000 above asking (27.1%) | $1.36M | $1,242 | 2bd 1ba 1,092sf | 0.72 mi | similar size | ||
| 719 Lakeview Ave | 2026-02-26 | $1.26M | $1,198,800 | $66,200 above asking (5.5%) | $1.35M | $1,288 | 3bd 2ba 1,050sf | 0.65 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 24 Victoria St | 2026-05-26 | $1.45M | $995,000 | $455,000 above asking (45.7%) | $1.5M | $1,082 | 2bd 2ba 1,387sf | 0.56 mi | |||
| 29 Concord St | 2026-05-12 | $1.16M | $859,000 | $301,000 above asking (35.0%) | $1.2M | $836 | 3bd 2ba 1,435sf | 0.73 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 12 Lobos St | 2026-09-28 | $920K | No asking price | — | $920K | $563 | 3bd 2ba 1,634sf | 0.42 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 142 Concord St | 2026-07-07 | $735K | No asking price | — | $782K | $763 | 2bd 1ba 1,025sf | 0.70 mi | |||
| 85 Concord St | 2026-04-13 | $1.02M | $759,000 | $266,000 above asking (35.0%) | $1.05M | $1,035 | 2bd 2ba 1,015sf | 0.73 mi | |||
| 211 Sadowa St | 2026-01-02 | $1.02M | No asking price | — | $1.19M | $1,340 | 3bd 1ba 887sf | 0.30 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 34 Brighton Ave | 2025-12-29 | $1.23M | $1,275,000 cut from $1.3M | $41,000 below asking (3.2%) | $1.46M | $1,028 | 3bd 2ba 1,420sf | 0.66 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 140 Moneta Way | 2026-07-13 | $1.1M | $1,109,888 cut from $1.16M | $9,888 below asking (0.9%) | $1.17M | $665 | 4bd 3ba 1,760sf | 0.32 mi | |||
| 171 Margaret Ave | 2025-11-20 | $1.13M | $950,000 | $175,000 above asking (18.4%) | $1.31M | $905 | 3bd 2ba 1,447sf | 0.50 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 230 Rhine St | 2025-11-03 | $990K | $898,000 | $92,000 above asking (10.2%) | $1.15M | $748 | 4bd 3ba 1,541sf | 0.39 mi | |||
| 14 Jules Ave | 2026-03-25 | $1.58M | $1,199,888 | $380,112 above asking (31.7%) | $1.64M | $1,185 | 3bd 2ba 1,385sf | 0.71 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 238 Victoria St | 2025-12-09 | $925K | No asking price | — | $1.09M | $1,013 | 1ba 1,081sf | 0.67 mi | similar size | ||
| 502 Plymouth Ave | 2025-11-25 | $1.1M | $988,000 | $112,000 above asking (11.3%) | $1.28M | $1,349 | 2bd 1ba 950sf | 0.40 mi | |||
| 232 Sagamore St | 2026-09-10 | $1.35M | $899,000 | $451,000 above asking (50.2%) | $1.35M | $710 | 3bd 1ba 1,902sf | 0.32 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 183 Victoria St | 2026-08-13 | $1.2M | $999,980 cut from $1.25M | $200,020 above asking (20.0%) | $1.27M | $773 | 3bd 2ba 1,639sf | 0.65 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 14 Moneta Ct | 2026-08-10 | $1.22M | No asking price | — | $1.29M | $774 | 3bd 2ba 1,665sf | 0.43 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 307 De Long St | 2026-03-10 | $950K | $850,000 | $100,000 above asking (11.8%) | $986K | $1,066 | 2bd 1ba 925sf | 0.52 mi | |||
| 29 Cassandra Ct | 2026-04-22 | $580K | $649,000 | $69,000 below asking (10.6%) | $594K | $699 | 1bd 1ba 850sf | 0.37 mi | |||
| 35 Guttenberg St | 2025-11-25 | $1.13M | $949,000 | $181,000 above asking (19.1%) | $1.32M | $869 | 3bd 2ba 1,515sf | 0.64 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 239 Bright St | 2026-07-16 | $1.52M | $1,280,000 | $238,000 above asking (18.6%) | $1.61M | $985 | 4bd 3ba 1,639sf | 0.61 mi | |||
| 715 Lakeview Ave | 2026-10-13 | $1.65M | $1,295,000 | $355,000 above asking (27.4%) | $1.58M | $871 | 3bd 3ba 1,816sf | 0.65 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 142 Montana Street | 2026-10-09 | $785K | $900,000 cut from $1M | $115,000 below asking (12.8%) | $752K | $963 | 2bd 1ba 781sf | 0.53 mi | recent | ||
| 2629 San Jose Ave | 2026-01-07 | $1.27M | $1,099,950 | $170,050 above asking (15.5%) | $1.48M | $951 | 3bd 2ba 1,556sf | 0.52 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 39 Caine Ave | 2026-04-06 | $147K | No asking price | — | $150K | $172 | 1ba 875sf | 0.62 mi | |||
| 423 Lakeview Ave | 2026-06-08 | $1.25M | $998,000 | $252,000 above asking (25.3%) | $1.3M | $712 | 3bd 2ba 1,820sf | 0.59 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 144 Lakeview Ave | 2026-04-22 | $1M | No asking price | — | $1.02M | $616 | 2ba 1,663sf | 0.57 mi | |||
| 785 Lakeview Ave | 2026-09-24 | $1.7M | $1,495,000 | $205,000 above asking (13.7%) | $1.7M | $983 | 3bd 2ba 1,730sf | 0.71 mi | 3 bd, recent | ||
| 212 Minerva St | 2025-11-03 | $1.19M | No asking price | — | $1.39M | $888 | 4bd 3ba 1,560sf | 0.52 mi | |||
| 900 Huron Ave | 2025-11-12 | $1.37M | $1,395,000 | $25,000 below asking (1.8%) | $1.6M | $812 | 4bd 3ba 1,965sf | 0.18 mi | |||
| 336 Louisburg St | 2026-06-12 | $1.65M | $1,345,000 | $305,000 above asking (22.7%) | $1.71M | $1,010 | 3bd 2ba 1,693sf | 0.70 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 227 Sargent St | 2026-01-13 | $847K | No asking price | — | $987K | $1,039 | 1ba 950sf | 0.70 mi | |||
| 55 Majestic Ave | 2026-07-10 | $1.52M | $1,388,000 | $137,000 above asking (9.9%) | $1.62M | $1,018 | 5bd 4ba 1,594sf | 0.61 mi | |||
| 2679 Alemany Blvd | 2026-07-28 | $1.6M | $1,299,000 | $301,000 above asking (23.2%) | $1.7M | $926 | 4bd 3ba 1,839sf | 0.49 mi | |||
| 233 Sargent St | 2025-11-17 | $1.23M | $1,199,613 | $30,387 above asking (2.5%) | $1.43M | $961 | 3bd 2ba 1,490sf | 0.70 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 322 Victoria St | 2026-10-09 | $850K | No asking price | — | $815K | $1,043 | 2bd 1ba 781sf | 0.73 mi | recent | ||
| 77 Ottawa Ave | 2026-03-30 | $1.7M | $1,388,000 | $312,000 above asking (22.5%) | $1.77M | $927 | 3bd 4ba 1,905sf | 0.65 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 270 Lobos St | 2026-05-29 | $485K | No asking price | — | $502K | $669 | 2bd 1ba 750sf | 0.53 mi | |||
| 406 Head St | 2026-07-21 | $1.23M | $998,000 cut from $1.39M | $232,000 above asking (23.2%) | $1.31M | $743 | 5bd 3ba 1,762sf | 0.60 mi | |||
| 229 Hanover St | 2026-05-19 | $1.35M | $998,000 | $352,000 above asking (35.3%) | $1.4M | $797 | 3bd 3ba 1,752sf | 0.72 mi | 3 bd | ||
| 267 Ramsell St | 2026-01-16 | $940K | No asking price | — | $1.1M | $1,328 | 1ba 825sf | 0.75 mi | |||
| 759 Lakeview Ave | 2026-08-12 | $1.6M | $1,399,000 | $201,000 above asking (14.4%) | $1.69M | $830 | 4bd 3ba 2,037sf | 0.68 mi | recent | ||
| 25 Ramsell St | 2026-02-17 | $1.68M | $1,495,000 | $180,000 above asking (12.0%) | $1.79M | $975 | 4bd 4ba 1,836sf | 0.63 mi | |||
| 519 Orizaba Ave | 2026-06-25 | $1.67M | $1,395,000 | $273,000 above asking (19.6%) | $1.73M | $946 | 4bd 3ba 1,828sf | 0.75 mi | |||
| 349 Hanover St | 2025-11-20 | $525K | No asking price | — | $611K | $803 | 1ba 761sf | 0.64 mi | |||
| 274 Montana St | 2025-12-10 | $1.62M | $1,388,000 | $232,000 above asking (16.7%) | $1.92M | $913 | 4bd 4ba 2,100sf | 0.63 mi | |||
| 631 Morse St | 2026-04-22 | $1.53M | $995,000 | $533,000 above asking (53.6%) | $1.57M | $738 | 5bd 3ba 2,123sf | 0.59 mi |