251 Athens St
Single-family home, 5 bd, 2 ba, 1,856 sqft, built 1956
40 sales inside 0.35 mi since May 2025. Click a sale on the map, or untick it below, to leave it out.
Drag the circle or this strip to change the searchEstimated sale price today
Low confidence
$1,584,000
$1,029,000estimated range$2,138,000
From 40 comps at a weighted median of $853 per sqft.
- Block
- 6005
- Lot
- 020
- Sales
- Nov 2025 to Oct 2026
- Prices adjusted to
- 2026-11-03
- Within
- 0.35 mi
- Sold since
- May 2025
Sale prices versus asking
Similarity-weighted median: 30.5% above final asking.
Middle half: at asking to 41.5% above asking. 29 of 40 selected comps have a verified final asking price.
Comparable sales (40)
Every sale inside the circle starts ticked, most similar first. Untick one here, or click it on the map, to leave it out.
| Address | Sold | Price | Final asking | Sale vs. asking | Adj. today | $/sqft | Size | Dist. | Why | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 227 Athens St | 2026-08-28 | $2.2M | $1,550,000 | $650,000 above asking (41.9%) | $2.35M | $1,137 | 4bd 4ba 2,065sf | <0.05 mi | nearby on same street, recent | |
| 18 Prague St | 2026-03-06 | $1.5M | $1,500,000 | At asking | $1.58M | $853 | 4bd 4ba 1,850sf | 0.15 mi | similar size | |
| 263 Naples St | 2026-03-24 | $1.37M | $1,385,000 | $17,000 below asking (1.2%) | $1.44M | $741 | 5bd 3ba 1,944sf | 0.10 mi | similar size, 5 bd | |
| 262 Naples St | 2026-04-22 | $1.65M | $1,198,000 | $452,000 above asking (37.7%) | $1.71M | $866 | 4bd 3ba 1,975sf | 0.13 mi | similar size | |
| 339 Madison St | 2026-08-13 | $1.75M | $1,329,000 | $421,000 above asking (31.7%) | $1.87M | $1,148 | 4bd 3ba 1,626sf | 0.26 mi | recent | |
| 247 Madrid St | 2026-06-30 | $1.15M | $1,288,000 | $138,000 below asking (10.7%) | $1.2M | $741 | 5bd 3ba 1,625sf | 0.20 mi | 5 bd | |
| 436 Edinburgh St #438 Price inferred from public records | 2026-07-17 | $1.2M | — | — | $1.29M | $646 | 1ba 2,000sf | 0.30 mi | similar size | |
| 134 Athens St | 2026-01-23 | $950K | No asking price | — | $1.12M | $526 | 4bd 3ba 2,135sf | 0.15 mi | same street | |
| 126 Madrid St | 2026-06-18 | $1.19M | $1,095,000 | $93,000 above asking (8.5%) | $1.24M | $554 | 5bd 2ba 2,246sf | 0.28 mi | 5 bd | |
| 273 Edinburgh St | 2026-07-20 | $1.72M | $1,268,000 | $447,000 above asking (35.3%) | $1.85M | $1,025 | 3bd 2ba 1,800sf | 0.16 mi | similar size | |
| 408 Athens St | 2026-02-24 | $900K | No asking price | — | $977K | $480 | 4bd 2.5ba 2,034sf | 0.21 mi | same street, similar size | |
| 331 Lisbon St | 2026-06-08 | $1.55M | $1,188,000 | $362,000 above asking (30.5%) | $1.62M | $943 | 5bd 3ba 1,720sf | 0.34 mi | similar size, 5 bd | |
| 106 Madrid St | 2026-07-17 | $34K | No asking price | — | $36K | $21 | 3bd 2ba 1,745sf | 0.29 mi | similar size | |
| 32 Madrid St | 2026-07-06 | $618K | No asking price | — | $665K | $391 | 3bd 2ba 1,700sf | 0.31 mi | similar size | |
| 495 Edinburgh St | 2025-12-30 | $800K | No asking price | — | $954K | $429 | 5bd 3ba 2,225sf | 0.34 mi | 5 bd | |
| 366 Harvard St | 2025-11-05 | $1.21M | $998,000 | $212,000 above asking (21.2%) | $1.42M | $871 | 4bd 2ba 1,628sf | 0.35 mi | ||
| 89 Naples St | 2026-03-10 | $1.72M | $1,388,000 | $332,000 above asking (23.9%) | $1.81M | $848 | 4bd 3ba 2,135sf | 0.23 mi | ||
| 32 Edinburgh St | 2026-05-29 | $2.35M | $1,595,000 | $757,000 above asking (47.5%) | $2.46M | $1,053 | 4bd 4ba 2,340sf | 0.31 mi | ||
| 70 Ina Ct | 2026-04-21 | $1.55M | $1,195,000 | $360,000 above asking (30.1%) | $1.61M | $1,247 | 2bd 1ba 1,293sf | 0.07 mi | ||
| 64 Vienna St | 2026-08-04 | $960K | $898,000 | $62,000 above asking (6.9%) | $1.02M | $793 | 3bd 1ba 1,292sf | 0.26 mi | recent | |
| 258 Harvard St | 2025-12-22 | $1.25M | No asking price | — | $1.49M | $931 | 2bd 2ba 1,600sf | 0.35 mi | ||
| 38 Edinburgh St | 2026-10-09 | $1.01M | No asking price | — | $973K | $798 | 1ba 1,218sf | 0.30 mi | recent | |
| 318 Avalon Ave | 2026-05-22 | $1.5M | $1,095,000 | $410,000 above asking (37.4%) | $1.58M | $1,190 | 3bd 2ba 1,325sf | 0.26 mi | ||
| 89 Athens St | 2026-04-10 | $1.35M | $948,000 | $402,000 above asking (42.4%) | $1.4M | $1,075 | 3bd 2ba 1,302sf | 0.21 mi | same street | |
| 330 Harvard St | 2026-01-02 | $1.3M | No asking price | — | $1.54M | $631 | 5bd 3ba 2,439sf | 0.34 mi | 5 bd | |
| 433 Excelsior Ave | 2026-06-18 | $1.5M | $1,195,000 | $305,000 above asking (25.5%) | $1.57M | $1,185 | 3bd 2ba 1,325sf | 0.20 mi | ||
| 724 Excelsior Ave | 2026-03-13 | $1.1M | $899,000 | $201,000 above asking (22.4%) | $1.16M | $901 | 2bd 2ba 1,285sf | 0.08 mi | ||
| 270 Athens St | 2025-11-17 | $1.26M | $995,000 | $270,000 above asking (27.1%) | $1.48M | $1,289 | 3bd 2ba 1,150sf | <0.05 mi | nearby on same street | |
| 69 Lisbon St | 2026-04-03 | $1.41M | $995,000 | $413,000 above asking (41.5%) | $1.46M | $1,123 | 3bd 2ba 1,300sf | 0.28 mi | ||
| 327 Brazil Ave | 2026-06-12 | $1.01M | $998,888 | $13,612 above asking (1.4%) | $1.06M | $791 | 3bd 1ba 1,340sf | 0.30 mi | ||
| 28 Madison St | 2026-10-23 | $1.2M | $949,000 | $251,000 above asking (26.4%) | $1.15M | $1,045 | 2bd 1ba 1,100sf | 0.34 mi | recent | |
| 232 Gambier Street | 2026-05-29 | $1.38M | $1,098,000 | $277,000 above asking (25.2%) | $1.44M | $1,299 | 3bd 2ba 1,109sf | 0.30 mi | ||
| 447 Silver Ave | 2025-12-12 | $975K | $929,000 | $46,000 above asking (5.0%) | $1.16M | $833 | 3bd 2ba 1,396sf | 0.34 mi | ||
| 306 Gambier St | 2026-05-22 | $1.33M | $988,000 | $342,000 above asking (34.6%) | $1.39M | $1,327 | 2bd 1ba 1,050sf | 0.29 mi | ||
| 30 Naples St | 2026-04-13 | $800K | No asking price | — | $829K | $778 | 2bd 1ba 1,066sf | 0.31 mi | ||
| 177 Edinburgh St | 2026-10-06 | $960K | $950,000 | $10,000 above asking (1.1%) | $920K | $897 | 2bd 1ba 1,025sf | 0.18 mi | recent | |
| 116 Madrid St | 2026-03-18 | $1.02M | $975,000 | $45,000 above asking (4.6%) | $1.07M | $954 | 3bd 2ba 1,125sf | 0.29 mi | ||
| 268 Madison St | 2026-01-29 | $2.1M | $1,688,000 | $412,000 above asking (24.4%) | $2.48M | $794 | 6bd 4ba 3,128sf | 0.24 mi | ||
| 340 Munich St | 2026-07-31 | $1.2M | $999,999 | $200,001 above asking (20.0%) | $1.29M | $1,194 | 3bd 2ba 1,082sf | 0.26 mi | ||
| 291 Munich St | 2025-11-06 | $1.1M | No asking price | — | $1.29M | $1,156 | 3bd 2ba 1,115sf | 0.20 mi |
What other buyers offered
No one has reported a losing offer on this home yet. Lost a bid here? Sign in to add yours, so the next buyer sees how far over asking it really went.